Witch pokemon game should I buy?

i have heartgold and it rocks. but they are almost the same game so its your choice. :)

Its actually up to you. Gold has Ho Ho and Silver has lugia. In my opinion, i like Gold. But they are the same.

Actually, everyone who answered is wrong. You can get both Ho-oh and Lugia in both Heart Gold and Soul Silver. They are basically the same game, but I chose Soul Silver because I liked the name better. Look it up, you can get both legendaries.