Girls, if you watch a chick flick with a guy is he boyfriend material or just a friend?

Okay, let's see...
We really shouldn't put men in the stereotype that they can only watch action/horror and stuff like that. Guys can like chick flicks too.
It's a bit of a paradox. It's OK for a woman to be tough, but it's not OK for a guy to be a romantic movie-watching sissy.
Sorry, that's just the way it is. I don't make the rules.

I feel as though if he's willing to go through two or so hours (whether they like it or not), he's definitely boyfriend material!

I mean, make your girl watch movies alone?? OR snuggle with her and make her feel safe when the guy chooses the wrong girl in the movie, so SHE knows she picked the right guy?? I would definitely go the latter

DEFINITELY BOYFRIEND MATERIAL!!!!!!
but then again it's also really based on how he talks to you, the way he behaves when you're around and how he reacts to your name!

Both, it depends on the situation. You'll have to assess the situation when you're watching the movie.