Update: My cousin have 2 cats and im going to choose one of them to adopt. But who should i going to pick?

Wilkie the cat is playful, funny, cute and dometicated. But hes not eating any cat food, he only want to eat is fish., anything human food, unhealthy so thats why his thin... He had no chance to eat some cat food dry or wet because mycousin tried everything. his lifestyle and personality is perfect to our family except him feeding routine.
Update 2: Orieo the cat is charming, playful and funny. He pis also perfect to our family and his feeding routine is perfect. He eats want cats should eat. His lifestyle, is fine but not as Perfect as Wilkie does. Hes good. Also love to pet like wilkie. Sometimes hes not petted, sometimes he wants to pet, mostly when hes hungry, hes not a lap cat but there is a time that he likes being in my lap.

So, who am i going to pick one of them.?